Cue the rants from people that don't understand why you are right. There were a number of obvious and rudimentary things these three could have done to make their actions "research" rather than "pranks." They did none of them. They would have needed to control for several variables. The most basic would have been to submit actual papers to the same publishers and perform analysis to determine whether real versus fake articles were published at different rates. Then of course there's the equally obvious plan to submit some with fake data with the opposite results and conclusions and see if one gets accepted at a different rate.
Maybe they weren't actually trying to prove anything. Maybe their objective is just to get all silly-sounding research to cease. That would be a sad day for science.
The fact that they had to stop their "research" early because they got found out just proves that journals aren't as dumb as they used to be.
It's a well-known problem with scientific journals that they are not robust against falsified data. This isn't really news. Did they attempt to submit fake articles that went against whatever they perceive to be the bias of the journals in question? From what I have read, they did not. Thus, they really only proved that falsified data can get an article published, which is something we knew. It proves nothing about the correlation between data quality and political leanings of the editors/reviewers. And honestly, the dildo article doesn't really even come to an interesting conclusion.
Worse than "ethical issues," Dr. B should be fired for not knowing how to successfully implement a social experiment so that it actually proves or disproves his hypothesis. I don't have a problem with him being an asshole making fun of other assholes. I have a problem with him wasting everybody's time by not designing the experiment correctly.
That being said, the new version of Windows really sucks; I'm putting off upgrading as long as possible. If you're ok with Mac's foibles, I recommend just sticking with that.
Utility is when you have one telephone, luxury is when you have two, opulence is when you have three -- and paradise is when you have none. -- Doug Larson