Comment Re:It's got nothing to do with appeal (Score 0) 58
One has to put this in perspective. On the rdos "Aspie Quiz" (which, at least of the previous version, followed the official diagnostic procedures for autism extremely closely and accurately measured "autism levels"), I score 178 out of 200, well into the upper range for autism. I've been officially dxed with autism and complex ADHD. Amongst a bunch of other stuff.
I hyperfixate (though generally not on Slashot, interestingly, although again there are exceptions), and my language will, at times, get blunt. And, yes, have been known to do all the other things you list. Although I do make some sort of effort to keep it at levels others can tolerate. Sometimes, I even actually succeed in this.
As a result, I think I can reasonably and fairly say that autistic people generally don't fit rsilvergun's profile. In fact, I suspect that the number of people on the ASD spectrum on Slashdot is well above the background level and quite plausibly much higher than in even the sciences. I could be wrong, there, of course. That does occasionally happen(!). So "autistic" (even "severely autistic") doesn't reflect actual behaviour in quite the way that the "standard image" portrays.
And that's one of the biggest alarm bells you can ever have with this condition. I've been in autistic groups where half the participants can't ever leave specialised care, and even those never ticked all of the boxes. If you see someone who DOES tick all the boxes, it is of course possible that they are autistic, but the underlying neurology of the condition (which is highly complex) strongly suggests that they can't have all those behaviours because of autism. Almost certainly, at least some behaviours are a fiction, even if it's not easy to figure out which ones are real and which ones aren't. And if some of them aren't genuine, you can't trust that any of them are.
Remote diagnosis is a dangerous game, but if someone exhibits two symtoms that appear in a description but cannot actually coexist, that's the time to stop trusting what they say.