Comment Re:Wrongdoing (Score 1) 20
Ummm... This is what bothers you?
Let's assume Anthropic is a business. It's even likely they would be happy to pay a fair licensing fee based on profits. It certainly would be easier. But, they will probably be hit with lawsuit after lawsuit so to survive, they need to pay as little as possible per suit.
Now, there are the lawyers. They might find a group of tens of thousands of people to represent. Since they established the group, there is no leader or clear representative for the group, so the lawyers choose one themselves. They each decide they want to make at least $1 million from the suit. That means two lawyers need to settle for about $7-8 million. So they sue for billions. Eventually, the lawyers talk to anthropic lawyers and say "this is your chance. For only $8 million, you can set a precedent. My clients will claim that this was a win for them, you'll end up paying each claimant about $32 and you'll gain legal rights to unlimited use of their stuff. Best of all, other lawyers hoping for a big win will know $32 is what to target."
So, Anthropic writes the settlement, the lawyers each get their million and the artists receive a mail worded to land in spam. The payout company pays about 25% of the claimants and after 2 year of holding the rest in escrow, the lawyer and payout company split the difference.
But, ok... Yeh... Anthropic is the evil one here
Let's assume Anthropic is a business. It's even likely they would be happy to pay a fair licensing fee based on profits. It certainly would be easier. But, they will probably be hit with lawsuit after lawsuit so to survive, they need to pay as little as possible per suit.
Now, there are the lawyers. They might find a group of tens of thousands of people to represent. Since they established the group, there is no leader or clear representative for the group, so the lawyers choose one themselves. They each decide they want to make at least $1 million from the suit. That means two lawyers need to settle for about $7-8 million. So they sue for billions. Eventually, the lawyers talk to anthropic lawyers and say "this is your chance. For only $8 million, you can set a precedent. My clients will claim that this was a win for them, you'll end up paying each claimant about $32 and you'll gain legal rights to unlimited use of their stuff. Best of all, other lawyers hoping for a big win will know $32 is what to target."
So, Anthropic writes the settlement, the lawyers each get their million and the artists receive a mail worded to land in spam. The payout company pays about 25% of the claimants and after 2 year of holding the rest in escrow, the lawyer and payout company split the difference.
But, ok... Yeh... Anthropic is the evil one here