Want to read Slashdot from your mobile device? Point it at m.slashdot.org and keep reading!

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror

Comment Re:I have multiple opinions (Score 3, Interesting) 49

It's not exactly like training a person, because human brains and computers are different, additionally a human looking at art is generally what the art is for and the human getting greater understanding of art at the same time is a bit of a side-effect.

That said, it's not exactly like making a copy either. It's generally undefined in legal terms, because laws have been written on the assumption that a person looking at it or some kind of literal copying procedure are the only important things which are done with art, but it exists in a space somewhere in between the two, having elements of both.

Comment It's fundamentally unknowable (Score 2, Insightful) 186

There is no way to tell whether anything which isn't human is conscious. There is no test which you can devise which will give one result if the subject is conscious and a different result if it is not. Even when it comes to other humans, you need some sort of reasoning like "well, I am when not in deep sleep, and this is fundamental to my behaviour, and I seem to follow the same basic behavioural tendencies as those around me..." Even if you build an AI which does absolutely everything a human can do including describing feelings which change in the same way as human feelings do etc, you can't demonstrate that it's conscious and isn't just behaving like that. And equally, you can't demonstrate that emacs is not conscious. Everything is unknowably conscious.

Comment Re:Loathing (Score 2) 41

A lot of the time when you hear some complete bullshit reasoning from the powerful like this, it's not supposed to be either an attempt to engage with reality or an attempt to convince anyone, it's more like a social cohesion mantra for their friend group. This friend group is typically powered by shared interests and collusion amongst its rich and powerful members, and its less powerful members dealing with their fears and insecurities by identifying with something which projects strength.

Comment Permanently wrong time is silly (Score 0) 159

If you're going to have the same UTC+? time throughout the year, that should be chosen so that the sun is at its highest point at noon somewhere close to the centre of the zone using this time. If this means you're doing things at the wrong time, change the time at which you do these things, don't make time itself perpetually silly. The only sensible reason to have time where the sun sometimes peaks in the wrong place is if you want to change the sun-based time at which you do things between winter and summer.

Comment Seems fair actually (Score 3, Insightful) 36

Most of the stuff "AI" is heavily marketed for is stuff that it cannot actually do properly, but this seems like an area where it can actually be useful. Things like textures in a game are not the focus of the creative effort, they mostly don't really need to express human creativity, they just need to be there and to be good enough. You don't normally gaze at a wall hoping it will inspire you or make you feel something whilst playing a game.

Comment How is this supposed to actually work? (Score 1) 129

So, nobody has the faintest idea how to actually go about building a super-intelligent AI. (Unless some very clever people are keeping a very big secret somewhere.) So what's the ban supposed to apply to? And if and when people do figure out something, banning it in a few countries isn't going to help.

Comment Re:Pearl Harbor .. never forget. (Score 1) 41

As if Japan is the only country to have ever attacked other countries. (BTW, If you want to paint the country from nearly a century ago in a bad light, something like the civilians of Nanjing would be a better choice.) Anyway, any "AI" worthy of the term or of great importance to the world shouldn't have to rape the whole internet before it can work properly and then fail to operate within any legal or ethical codes, it should be able to learn just from inputs from consenting sources and have some idea about things it should do and things it shouldn't do.

Slashdot Top Deals

Computers are useless. They can only give you answers. -- Pablo Picasso

Working...