Comment Re:He's wrong (Score 1) 235
Button presses fail (to achieve the desired result) frequently in my cars. There's the state dependent cruise control on/off/enable/disable button which is sufficiently overloaded that pushing it often results in unwanted disabling of the system, or failure to activate it. This feature seems to be related to safety regulations or ratings, because my 1994 car's cruise control avoided the confusion by simply not having an "off" state that served no functional purpose. There's the shift lever (a fancy schmancy button) in my wife's car, which puts the car into a disabled state if operated too soon in the start up process. Launching this car is like starting in a race, if you don't wait for the starting signal, you are penalized! There are the oh so smart window controls in my 2014 electric car that choose between auto up/down and manual based on who knows what, but never, ever want to stop 1 cm from the top where I occasionally like to leave them for ventilation. There were also the Lucas switches in my '69 MG, but I loved them for for all their failings.
There are well designed buttons, and, well, not nice ones. My favorite button was the crown of a Breitling Aerospace, a quartz watch with both digital and analog displays, with a non-complicated appearance. One button scrolled though menus, set the time or timer, silenced the alarm, etc, and you never felt like there was the least bit of wasted motion. The electric window button in an old Bentley was a bit like this, it did the same job as other electric window buttons of the day, but somehow a little bit better.
That said, the idea of trying to find the right spot on a touchscreen while driving is downright scary; Having to announce to my passengers that I need my seat temperature lowered just seems rude. So I don't see a Rivian in my future. Fortunately, the likes of VW and Porsche have reversed themselves on touchscreen controls, reintroducing physical controls on some models, so I still have hope.