Comment Re:Ok ? But who's going to host it ? (Score 3, Insightful) 29
And since people aren't tech savvy enough to host the data themselves, or don't have proper infrastructure to do so, where do you think all these repositories of data will end up ? Azure, AWS, GCP. Now instead of a free X account or Instagram account, I need to pay Amazon to host my stuff that Reddit fetches to display to people.
This is has been a problem for a long time. In an ideal world, hosting data from one's own personal internet connection, be it from one's phone, work, wherever, should not be as difficult as it is. And it shouldn't have to involve anyone other than one's primary service provider. We should be able to make direct connections, and receive email without a 3rd party service... at least no one other than whoever runs the connections along the route. It should be, by and large, private except to the sender and recipient with the exception of any routing data to get it the correct address.
But although this could in theory happen (and occasionally does from knowledgeable power-users with the right configuration and equipment), for the vast majority, it doesn't. And the problem is legion. No fixed IP addresses, NAT (even worse carrier grade NAT), DDOS attack protection, having to config a DMZ on a router, even just setting up a data source/website are some of the many, many problems. So of course, naturally all this gets offloaded to companies like AWS, Cloudflare, Google, and the big social networks because they make it easy. You likely have to pay, or pay by giving up your privacy, or both, but they take care of everything. You can find your own webhost, but again, it's like paying a third party to get your postal mail for you...because your mailbox is moving around, hundreds of people are trying to look through it or destroy it, or find a way into your house using it.
It doesn't have to be this way. But someone has to make it trivially easy to solve these problems without the big tech companies, and I'm not sure I see that happening anytime soon. Can we ban carrier grade NAT? Can we require internet providers to allow hosting and stop DDOS attacks? Is the cure worse than the pain now? I don't know what the answer is, but he has a point. We need to take back ownership of our data and the web