Comment Do plane fly? (Score 0) 103
Let's say we want to fly. Should we build a machine that flaps its wings like birds? Is flying defined as the act of flapping wings to generate lift?
The HOW is irrelevant. Helicopters, planes, gliders, none of them fly like birds do, but they get the job done. There is no point trying to do what nature does, we simply need to travel quickly from point A to point B, carry payload, entertain, explore, etc...
In the same sense, how AI achieves generating content is irrelevant. Whether there is intelligence, intuition, imagination, thinking, is just a philosophical circle jerk. What matters is that the machine achieves useful results, not how it got there.
Besides, asking: does AI think? is nonsense because there is no objective mathematical definition of what it means to "think". How can we objectively give a yes or no answer if we cannot precisely define what it means and test a model against that definition? All we have is a subjective notion of "think". Every person may have different opinions, all of them valid, hence, not useful. If you really want to answer the question, then start by drawing a clear line in the sand of what is and is not "thinking", something we can actually use to evaluate a machine.