Follow Slashdot stories on Twitter

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror

Comment Re:What about "hate speech"? (Score 1) 153

the report's authors

Europeans often smell themselves when it comes to the abstract idea of Liberty; in the concrete I prefer America's.

the abolition of "net neutrality" rules is a good thing, improving freedom.

Here though, we part company. Why is it Verizon's business that I have requested HTTP from Gab.com? Verizon and I have a contract to fulfill my HTTP requests for a certain charge per month. They have no business with Gab.com that I care about when making an HTTP request, and throttling my request makes the business relationship with Verizon much less worthwhile.

GoDaddy is not involved in Net Neutrality. I don't have a contract with GoDaddy to deliver HTTP to me.

Comment Re:What about "hate speech"? (Score 1) 153

As I argue elsewhere, providing a forum for the despicables is not — should not be — any more toxic, than defending same in court.

Here, we are in complete agreement. People who are crying for Gab's deplatforming are ignorant, short-sighted, slope-slippers. If you believe in free speech only for some, you don't believe in it at all.

That being said, you don't have to enable anyone else's speech. That is freedom, as well.

Comment Re:What about "hate speech"? (Score 1) 153

Yes, they have been persecuted in the commercial space, but I didn't think that's what we were talking about: that content wouldn't even have a chance of being hosted in Germany.

What I was saying is that a private entity which does not support Gab does not support the principles of free speech. That is, as you say, having it both ways.

However, preventing a private entity from terminating business arrangements or not entering into them does not strike me as a remedy. The current cycle of shaming and naming makes certain opinions completely, commercially-speaking, toxic. This is freedom, too.

Comment Re:What about "hate speech"? (Score 2) 153

Yeah, I'm pretty uncomfortable with them being deplatformed, too. I don't think that you can on the one hand say you support the principles of free expression and on the other say "Oh, well, that makes me uncomfortable."

On the other hand, no one has to pay for the bits which make up your speech, and the government isn't involved, so I'm not sure this is the exact hill on which to die.

Slashdot Top Deals

Beware of all enterprises that require new clothes, and not rather a new wearer of clothes. -- Henry David Thoreau

Working...