Comment So about those humanities classes... (Score 1) 132
Philosophically: The tech billionaires, AI investors, and the folks arguing "biological consciousness is of no greater worth than the future digital variety" have effectively adopted nihilism and rejected humanism. If I recall my old humanities classes correctly, both of these are fundamentally rationalist - to my knowledge, the only way to make a logical argument for the value of human existence is to found it on the subjective experience of wanting to exist.
Humanism (which is, IIRC, approximately the foundation for modern western civilization), embraces the required component of subjectivity and suggests we enjoy the ride and, you know, maybe not go around killing each other and destroying ourselves because:
- 1. Subjectively it sucks.
- 2. Objectively, the only way things can suck is subjectively, therefore if something sucks subjectively then
In the current context it looks to me like the relationship between humanism and nihilism on a spectrum of existentialism is becoming literal again. We either decide that we want to exist, and we're willing to do what is rationally necessary to support each other in existing, or we're out.
... and, yeah, that "biological consciousness is of no greater worth than the future digital variety" argument, is a literal declaration that the folks making this decision are perfectly happy to end your existence in pursuit of their nihilistic fantasies.