I am one of the lucky 1000, and have just got the letter from Sir Jonathan Stephens which apologises for the breach.
I wonder if there will be a class action? That would be pretty embarrassing for all concerned so I don't think it will happen. Esp as we have not actually received our awards yet, we will be invited to an investiture to given them by a senior member of the royal family (although we are allowed to use the title / letters now)
btw the people on the list are by and large not the wealthy elite. While I think this used to be the case, a lot of work goes on behind the scenes to make sure that the recipients are legitimate. I certainly never thought I would get a gong.
To get on the list you have to have achieved something, and this usually means giving up your own time for the public good, and if people suspect you are gong-hunting i.e." look at me doing charity work" then that will disqualify you.
Whether or not to have these type of awards is debatable, but it seems most countries have them in some form (although maybe not referencing their Empire!). I saw a quote from ?Rothschild
1 never seek an honour
2 if an honour is offered, then accept it with grace
3 never ever wear an honour
Happy new year !