Want to read Slashdot from your mobile device? Point it at m.slashdot.org and keep reading!

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror

Comment Re:No that's how capitalism works (Score 1) 122

this is about advertisers and what they want, and that's about what sells without turning off an audience.

Don't like it? Then make a government run public access version of YouTube. Then you can put whatever you want on there as long as it's legal. But that's socialism.

You do certainly have great trust in the government. Personally I would expect a government version of YouTube to implement much more censorship (content moderation, whatever you want to call it) than YouTube ever will if it gains a dominant market share (with the help of its political mothers and fathers).

Comment Re:What is the use case here? (Score 5, Insightful) 39

"I mean, if you want a snippet (like "how do I safely encrypt passwords"), you can already find plenty of solutions online."

Only if you are doing main stream development. I used to be a research but I am now a developer/domain expert in a very narrow field. I have often needed an implementation of a scientific algorithm. They are never available on Stack Overflow or similar. But there are often methods implementing these specific algorithms buried deep down in some anonymous GitHub repository created by a researcher in the field. So, that would be one use case.

Another less direct use case is that it may be useful for Github Copilot. But that is just me speculating.

Comment Re:India's going down too (Score 1) 152

We're not going to have migrants or even immigrants to speak of much anymore, because no country is going to let what few young folk they have leave.

Yes, the fertility rates in Africa are trending downwards. But the rates are still very high and it will take a long time for them to come down. In the meantime the population in Africa will grow from 1.3 billion (16% of global population) to 2.4 billion (26% of global population) by 2050. This will (and already is) create a large immigration wave. It will mainly be internal migration in Africa and migration towards Europe due to the proximity but USA will of course also receive a share of the migration.

The migration wave from Africa will as you say end. But the population growth in that region does still have a large momentum combined with inadequate domestic opportunities with the obvious result being mass migration over the coming decades.

Comment Re:Already happening (Score 1) 152

Israel succeeded, at least until very recently. Turns out what you need is a society that makes it possible to have children and views it as a normative good, a society that doesn't pump its kids full of chemicals and teach them that the slightest awkwardness during puberty is a sign they should sterilize themselves, and most importantly the ability to actually buy a home and support a family.

Israel has succeeded at maintaining (a high) population growth primarily because it has a large religiously orthodox segment in society that has an extremely high fertility rate. Haredi jews have a growth rate of 5% (doubling approximately every 14 years) while non-Haredi jews have a growth rate of 1.2% (doubling every 60 years or so). From https://ancillary-proxy.atarimworker.io?url=https%3A%2F%2Fen.wikipedia.org%2Fwiki%2F.... It is however also clear that this will change Israel fundamentally over the coming decades.

Comment Re:How about Re-Criminalizing Crime? (Score 2) 168

You've misunderstood the subsidy I'm objecting to. I am not an anarcho-capitalist, and am in favor of public spending for police, prosecutors, defenders, judges, and jail . But the videos of people stealing from Walgreens often suggest that the police should patrol in sufficient numbers to deter shoplifters; it doesn't make sense use $125,000 of police power to protect (very generously) $100,000 of Walgreens merchandise.

Your calculation is too simplistic. The societal costs of crime are much higher than the value of the stolen goods. A Walgreen adds value (better health, higher property prices) to the surrounding society. This value is lost if it is forced to shut down due to theft.

Comment Re:It seems kind of weird (Score 1) 248

So either way we're not likely to get much above the 8 billion that we're at now. Heck even China and India are having trouble growing their populations. In Africa won't be growing much longer if at all since they're rapidly modernizing.

The most recent UN projections do not show a decline in World population in the coming 50 years but rather an increase to around 10.5 billion with the population in Africa having by far the highest population growth rate of any continent. In 2022 the population of Africa is around 1.4 billion (17.7% of World population) while it is projected to reach 3.4 billion (32.2% of World population) in fifty years.

So what we will be seeing in the next 50 years will be rapid population growth in Africa (increase of around 2.4 times) while the populations in most of the rest of the World (excluding some countries like Pakistand and Afghanistan) will be stagnant or declining. At some point the population boom in Africa will end as well. But we are nowhere near the end of the current boom.

Comment Re:Zero-Google is harder than Zero-COVID (Score 1) 67

If Google chooses to protect the data according the to EU GDPR then they can resume selling their services to public schools in Denmark.

That will be hard as long Google is an US compagny which has to secretly hand over any data to any US agency that asks for it.

That is currently the case. But the coming Trans-Atlantic Data Privacy Framework which replaces the EU–US Privacy Shield (which did not give sufficient protections) will change that. See https://ancillary-proxy.atarimworker.io?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.tadpf.eu%2F

Comment Re:Zero-Google is harder than Zero-COVID (Score 1) 67

I'm sure China would lease their 'firewall'. As long as the source doesn't get out, there's money to be made. But that would just encourage people to find a way around it ten fold. Lather, rinse...

It is not illegal to use Google services in Denmark. It is illegal for municipalities (including public schools) to use services from a company which does not store this information in places where the data is safe (so, outside the EU since these are Danish students). If Google chooses to protect the data according the to EU GDPR then they can resume selling their services to public schools in Denmark.

Comment Re:Zero-Google is harder than Zero-COVID (Score 1) 67

Even If you've achieved Zero-Google, you going to do Zero-Microsoft next? In principle, the government has to check all the source code that runs on the local computer and compile it by yourself. And then build crazy big firewall in Denmark network. Is it possible today like in Denmark? I can't keep up with that stupid.

No, it is not enough to compile it yourself. You also have to create your own compiler since a compiler can do whatever it wants with your code, including inserting data collection and transmitting instructions. And you have to remove all non-open firmware.

In reality this is of course regulated by law instead. The GDPR forces companies to inform us about the data collection and handling that they are doing. And if Googles data collection and handling does not conform to the regulations that the schools have for handling student information then the schools cannot use Google services (the main problem here being information being sent to undisclosed locations outside EU). Simple as that. If Microsoft can provide a service which does conform to it then the schools can use their services.

Comment Re:Free ride problem (Score 1) 129

For example, what if the union(with criminals removed) handled retirement benefits in the worker's best interests? So, for example, companies couldn't raid the pension funds, because the union has them? I've heard complaints that businesses don't like training people any more. So what if the union did that? What if hte union provided the medical care options? Etc...

In my country pension funds are never controlled by companies (I think it may be illegal since it never happens). They simply transfer the agreed pension rate to the pension fund every month. But you are the actual customer of the pension fund (which also provide some insurance services). That is a much better solution than letting unions handle your pension funds.

Comment Re:Join the Club (Score 2, Insightful) 111

Scientology is still a cult.

It has an unreasonable amount of control over its members actions and thoughts.

Is the amount of control that more widespread religions, such as Christianity and Islam, have over its members actions and thoughts not unreasonable?

The main difference between cult and religion is that a cult is smaller, less organized and newer than a religion. Both Christianity and Islam started out as cults and grew into religions over time. The same is probably true for all religions.

Comment Re:it buys most of its solar modules from China at (Score 1) 418

Was merely correcting the OP, yes for Australia Solar is a no brainer. There is a lot of FUD that Australia does poorly on renewables, it actually does extremely well on Hydro, Solar and wind. Australia is quite well ahead of places like Germany and Spain, however it has fuck all to do with the Australian government who have been laggards and the bad rep comes from a few power plants and the emissions from transport and Ag (as well as Australia supplying large swaths of the world with coal). So Australia leads Europe comfortably, the Australian government is a long way behind most of Europe (even post the recent government change)

Australia emits 16.8 metric tons of CO2 per capita. EU emits under half that per capita. So how is that leading?

Comment Re:it buys most of its solar modules from China at (Score 1) 418

Australia is actually ahead of most of europe on renewables (despite a government for the last 10 years that has been in denial). Australia has 1 in 5 houses already with solar increasing by the day. Where Australia hasn't fared well is the large scale power generators or the emissions due to coal and also due to transport and agriculture (areas that due to distance they are unlikely to ever lead the world), rooftop solar they lead the world.

In 2018 Australia emitted 16.8 metric tons of CO2 per capita (which is more than USA) while France for example emitted 5.0 per capita: https://ancillary-proxy.atarimworker.io?url=https%3A%2F%2Fen.wikipedia.org%2Fwiki%2F...

And while most of the rest of the World is decreasing CO2 emissions per capita, Australia has flatlined.

Comment Re: Government Disinformation At Work (Score 1) 83

>old testament began which portrayed a God which was more remote and often less direct in the way he interacted with humans. And the new testament continued this tradition.

This link in your chain of reasoning doesn't make any sense. You are saying that an immanent God is "more remote" than a God in the Heavens? How, exactly?

More remote in the way that the deity influences the World. The new testament deity may be omnipresent but his presence is less linked to physical representations than previously. But even if you disagree (and you may have some valid arguments): My point is that there is a long term development in which religious explanations are being pushed back in area after area. If you for example compare Christian practice in the Medieval to Christian practice now you will see that many of the phenomena that were previously attributed to divine intervention is now explained by science without objection from present day Christians.

This development is obvious. When science has taken some ground we (almost) never see religions taking it back. And science is still taking ground from religions. That said, religious censorship may in the future change this course. Or religions may have luck in their attempts to transform deity-human interactions even further into inherently non-detectable interactions. No development is deterministic but my money is on science.

Slashdot Top Deals

Heuristics are bug ridden by definition. If they didn't have bugs, then they'd be algorithms.

Working...