Comment Re:Totally what I said it would be. (Score 3, Interesting) 126
ANYONE with that binary does have a right to that source code, so Red Hat would have to give access to the source code if a customer gave a binary to someone else.
Not quite true. If a customer gave a binary to someone else, the customer would have to give access to the source code to that someone else. Red Hat has no obligation in this case. This is because Red Hat uses 3(a) to distribute sources, not 3(b) or 3(c).
Under 3(a) when you download the binary from Red Hat, you have the option of downloading the sources from the same site at the same time. Once you download the sources, or choose not to, Red Hat's GPL obligation is complete[*]. You don't get to point at Red Hat and say "get the sources from them, not me" nor do you get to wait a year and come back crying because you didn't download the sources when you had the chance.
[*] technically, Red Hat's obligation continues as long as they continue to offer the binaries to you, but once the offer of the binary is withdrawn, the offer of the sources is no longer required.