tariffs are more limited hands off form of taxation than the alternatives.
if you don't want to pay them; buy something domestic or just hold onto your money.
The issue is that even "domestic" goods typically have parts sourced through imports, so you will pay a hidden "tariff tax" on most products anyway.
Compare that income or property taxes...
They main difference is transparency: with those taxes is far more easy to figure out exactly how much money goes into them out of your pockets. With tariffs you don't really know actually. There is a reason Trump threatened retaliation against Amazon when it was even only suggested they might make the tariff portion of the consumer price transparent to the consumer.
The limited hands off government I think we ought to have would eliminate income and property taxes and implement a national sales tax.
A sales tax would be unable to finance the government unless ridiculous cuts to the government's budget are made. DOGE tried that and failed miserably, so I don't see it happening any time soon.
The issue is that a high enough sales tax would drive tax evasion and require significant expenses in controls and enforcement. If you want such a high tax the only realistic option would be to switch to VAT, which has a built-in cross-check mechanism making evasion easier to control. It is otherwise functionally equivalent to a sales tax of equal magnitude, but due to the cross-checks it can be made much higher effectively as the EU and other VAT countries demonstrate.
The America first government I think we ought to have would enact strong tariffs to ensure domestic industry is protected and domestic alternative goods and products are preferred, but leave you free to import French wine and Chinese e-waste if you really really want to and are willing to pay the taxes..
That kind of "domestic industry" based on manufacturing is either going 2 ways: driven with super-cheap labor, or driven by automation. The former is not suitable for a first-world country like the US, whereas the latter is where things are going to go more likely, with more advanced manufacturers already having basically fully automated manufacturing facilities in operation.
Manufacturing as large employment sector in first world country has been on the way of the dodo for quite some time by now and I doubt there will be any other destination in the future, regardless of what happens with tariffs.