Seriously I'm tired of all of this discussion of what "filmmakers want," what about what I want? What I want is bright, clear pictures all the time, loud, clear dialogue, and quiet audio effects and music. Call me tasteless, but most of the time I have no control over ambient lighting and need to keep the volume under control to avoid disturbing people I live with.
Agree. I had a Philips Natural Motion(tm) tube 20+ years ago, and for PAL (25 fps) pictures it interpolated and doubled the frame rate to 50. For NTSC, where 24 fps film has 3:2 pulldown (every other frame is shown for 3 NTSC fields and other for 2), the effect was even better because it got rid of that slight stutter and, well, interpolated frame rate to 60 fps.
This was quite noticeable even on the DVD sources.
I was really happy when The Hobbit was filmed at 48 fps, but apparently that didn't catch on. Fine by me, but I'll take the interpolated frames anyway. I hate the jaggedness of 24 fps productions. Yeah, motion blur removes the worst parts of it (run a 3d shooter at 24 FPS without motion blur = looks horrible), but still better to just get more frames.
What I do not get is that even Disney/Pixar movies get rendered at 24 fps. Why in the hell is that? You can render at whatever speed you want, guys. Just make it an option to drop half the frames for traditionalists then, but give me my smoothness!