Comment Re:Youtube (Score 1) 181
That's the official line, but it's a blatant lie.
To the extent that Google cares about account recovery at all, they want it to go away, and you get a new account every time you get a new phone. They've been systematically *removing* ways to recover accounts. Among other things, you can't do it with an automated computer-generated-voice call (that reads you a one-time code) any more, and for a while now you haven't been able to do it with just your password once they have your phone number: you have to have the phone (or at least the same phone number), or the account is dead, full stop. Additionally, they keep making it harder and harder to log into your account from multiple different devices, because they do NOT want you doing that. They want every account tied inexorably to a specific individual smartphone, preferably an Android phone (though they also work with Apple, reluctantly, because Apple users are ridiculously loyal and too numerous and too moneyed to completely ignore). For the time being, if you've given them an email address that goes to a third-party email account (from e.g. an ISP or employer), you can still get a one-time code sent to that account every time, and thus log into the Google account from wherever you are on the network; but I expect that option to go away before too many more months pass. Also, needing to do it kind of defeats the main purpose of GMail. You *should* be able to just log in with your password, but that's no longer allowed, unless you are on the same device you've used before. So if you're ever going to get a new phone, better do it before you lose the old one, or the Google account will die.
I am *guessing* that the motivation behind all this, may have something to do with smartphone apps, and the lucrative nature thereof; but this is a guess.
To the extent that Google cares about account recovery at all, they want it to go away, and you get a new account every time you get a new phone. They've been systematically *removing* ways to recover accounts. Among other things, you can't do it with an automated computer-generated-voice call (that reads you a one-time code) any more, and for a while now you haven't been able to do it with just your password once they have your phone number: you have to have the phone (or at least the same phone number), or the account is dead, full stop. Additionally, they keep making it harder and harder to log into your account from multiple different devices, because they do NOT want you doing that. They want every account tied inexorably to a specific individual smartphone, preferably an Android phone (though they also work with Apple, reluctantly, because Apple users are ridiculously loyal and too numerous and too moneyed to completely ignore). For the time being, if you've given them an email address that goes to a third-party email account (from e.g. an ISP or employer), you can still get a one-time code sent to that account every time, and thus log into the Google account from wherever you are on the network; but I expect that option to go away before too many more months pass. Also, needing to do it kind of defeats the main purpose of GMail. You *should* be able to just log in with your password, but that's no longer allowed, unless you are on the same device you've used before. So if you're ever going to get a new phone, better do it before you lose the old one, or the Google account will die.
I am *guessing* that the motivation behind all this, may have something to do with smartphone apps, and the lucrative nature thereof; but this is a guess.