Comment Re:Maybe.. (Score 3, Interesting) 86
This is overly direct causality thinking and overlooks transitive benefits.
Older individuals often mentor, advise, and guide younger generations - supporting not just immediate reproduction, but higher-quality, more sustainable reproduction across generations. They can also shape longer-term thinking and more stable environments, which indirectly improve conditions for successful procreation.
By your logic, we might as well argue that "writing down accumulated knowledge in books doesn’t support optimal reproduction." But clearly, preserving and transmitting hard-earned wisdom gives later generations a significant head start.
There is a good reason that the human race is a social collective, and not just an ongoing pool of breeding meat.