Comment The prices are just better. (Score 1) 168
If you live in an area where there is actual competition between supermarkets, then perhaps Costco isn't a great deal. Where I live in the US, my choice is Safeway and Kroger. I think our local supermarkets know that they have a near monopoly, so they are happy to sell substandard product at premium prices and they NEVER compete with each other. The prices those places charge are always matching and just too high. The alternates are Whole Foods and Trader Joes on the other side of town, but the Costco is reasonably close.
When we do our Costco shop, we check the price per unit against the local Kroger and Safeway and generally Costco for the same name brands is usually 33% to 50% cheaper. The meat is also usually a good deal, and generally it's a lot better quality than Safeway,
We're one of those ingredient families, where we don't have that many pre-made meals, but we have the ingredients available to make a lot of meals.
Sure, we have to buy larger quantities, but it's always things that are shelf stable for a long time, such as canned items, or things we can portion out and freeze. We rarely have to throw anything away.
Here are a couple of examples from our recent purchases.
Bacon Crumbles (aka Bacon Bits): Costco, Kirkland Signature, 20oz is $9, so $0.45/oz. Kroger brand is $0.76/oz. Safeway store brand is $1.43/oz.
Nally Chilli: Costco is $0.10/oz. Safeway is $0.17/oz Kroger is $0.18/oz - Sure Costco is a dozen cans, but it's waaaay cheaper.
Top sirlon steak: Costco is $10/lb. Kroger is $11/lb and Safeway is $13/lb