Comment Re:AI not to blame? (Score 5, Insightful) 75
Stack Overflow messed up by not having a "close with explanation" option. They are too focused on experts and data quality.
If you understand How To Ask Questions, Stack Overflow is fantastic. I've had nothing but good experiences.
If you're a newbie, you will ask a question that you are so lost on that you'll get closed as a dupe of a question that seems unrelated to yours. The expert will have seen three layers deep into your issue and found the real problem, correctly closing it as a dupe.
On one hand, Stack Overflow gets to have clean data. On the other hand, that newbie doesn't understand why their question was closed, doesn't have their problem solved, and probably jumps on reddit saying how awful Stack Overflow is.
The person voting to close does not need to leave an explanation. A lot don't.