Comment Re:Wow! People finally get what Buffet said... (Score 1) 250
I'd agree with you that the blockchain can perform a role, as a register. The concepts behind it can help us do things, like the concept of an IOU and the concept of money helped us perform financial transactions over millennia. Technologies are useful, they help us do things faster / easier / differently. Bitcoin though? I'm unclear on how Bitcoin helps any communication... to me it's not a technology, it's the application of a technology.
As for the energy spent on Bitcoin to make it safe, that doesn't give it value, that means we spent (or in my words, wasted) something of value. At the end of the day, if people refuse to accept your Bitcoin as having value, it will not be used for anything, no matter how secure / distributed. The Bitcoin itself is nothing, it's just a virtual construct that does nothing. Gold can be used in semiconductors or jewelry, bacon/wheat can be eaten, oil is required to power our cars, etc. Those commodities have intrinsic value because they have usage. A piece of rock has value because at least it can be a paperweight (it's just low value because they're so easy to get). Bitcoin, even if rare, remains virtual and does nothing by itself. It's a virtual currency not used as a currency, hence the OP saying it's a solution looking for a problem.
As for the energy spent on Bitcoin to make it safe, that doesn't give it value, that means we spent (or in my words, wasted) something of value. At the end of the day, if people refuse to accept your Bitcoin as having value, it will not be used for anything, no matter how secure / distributed. The Bitcoin itself is nothing, it's just a virtual construct that does nothing. Gold can be used in semiconductors or jewelry, bacon/wheat can be eaten, oil is required to power our cars, etc. Those commodities have intrinsic value because they have usage. A piece of rock has value because at least it can be a paperweight (it's just low value because they're so easy to get). Bitcoin, even if rare, remains virtual and does nothing by itself. It's a virtual currency not used as a currency, hence the OP saying it's a solution looking for a problem.