Follow Slashdot stories on Twitter

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror

Comment Re:Reasoning (Score 1) 131

On what basis do you say "That's provably not the case." to my claim that the training needs to be applied while it's developing? If you've got a good reason, I'd like to hear it. My opinion is based on things like "The chain of logic" not reliably representing the eventual conclusion. It's far from rigorous, but I think it's strongly the "best guess".

Comment Re:That is a hell of a lot of jobs (Score 1) 89

It's not clear to me, though, that GPT5 is good enough. OTOH, I'm going off second and third (or more) hand reports.

That said, there are already definite use cases, and those will only increase. The question is "how quickly?". I wouldn't want to play John Henry vs. the steam drill, but many seem anxious to do just that.

Comment Re:This kind of thing makes me suspicious (Score 1) 131

That depends on what you mean by "machine". It is perfectly reasonable to have a meaning of machine that includes these effects. And you're right about the difference between utility and intelligence. A screwdriver may have very high utility, but has essentially no intelligence. OTOH, slime molds *are* intelligent. Not *very* intelligent, but still, intelligent. More than that, they're goal-seeking intelligences. It's not clear to me that pure LLMs are goal-seeking except in a very limited way. But they do have a bit of intelligence. It's different than the intelligence of a human or a slime mold, but it's there. (Understanding, perhaps not, or perhaps one should rather say "only in a linguistic context".)

Comment Re:Nonsequitur (Score 1) 131

There's no plausible reason to claim that it doesn't involve "some kind of irrational quantum mechanical voodoo", There's just no reason to claim that it does. FWIW, photosynthesis involves "some kind of irrational quantum mechanical voodoo" that allows multiple photons to energize the same reaction.

OTOH, involving quantum mechanics isn't a claim to non-locality, except at a REALLY sub-microscopic level.

Personally, I doubt that non-classical mechanics is required for consciousness, but quantum mechanics might be used to make it a lot more efficient. To me it appears that you get consciousness when you have self-monitoring goal-seekiing.

Comment It would be surprising if it wasn't shedding more (Score 5, Insightful) 34

It would be surprising if it wasn't shedding more heat than it receives from the sun:
Uranus is pretty distant from the sun, so it doesn't get much solar heating. Large blobs of gas tend to collapse, emitting heat in the process. Pieces of rock tend to have radioactive components. Etc.

That said, 12% seems a bit higher than I would expect.

Comment Re:Proliferation of distros is not a sign of vigor (Score 2) 48

I guess it did, and your response didn't clarify things. Suppose I listed the choices as
"Apple, Debian, Red Hat, Suse, Ubuntu, Windows"? Putting them in nice alphabetical order, and leaving out the choices that require a bit of tech knowledge. (I'm not sure about SUSE, but I suspect it's just as easy to use or install.)

The real limit is that most people don't install an OS, so they just use whatever their computer came with. The last time I installed windows it was harder to install than Debian...of course that was back in the 1990's. I haven't touched their updated TOS, and even in the 1990's I had someone else click through the requirements. (OTOH, Windows 95 and 98 were relatively easy to install...but then you needed to get all the drivers installed. So Debian was still easier...but that's not fair, because the Debian I'm comparing against is at least the 1998 version, and often one slightly later.)

Comment Re:Can we get a source that isn't The Guardian? (Score 1) 24

Which "The Guardian"? Certainly the one I kept getting in my mailbox was NOT reputable journalism. Perhaps "The Manchester Guardian" is reputable. But I've never seen a copy. And if the US edition of "The Guardian" (without adjectival mods) is the same company as the British edition, then neither one is trustworthy, as they just say what they think will sell. And they occasionally directly contradict each other.

Slashdot Top Deals

"Joy is wealth and love is the legal tender of the soul." -- Robert G. Ingersoll

Working...